Stargate: Atlantis – Sunday Review

  • Series Title: Stargate: Atlantis
  • Episode Title: Sunday
  • Story #: Season 3 Episode # 17
  • Discs: 1 (Part of “The Complete Third Season” – 5 discs total)
  • Network: Sci-Fi (MGM Productions)
  • Original Air Dates: 6/01/2007
  • Cast: Joe Flanigan, David Hewlett, Jason Momoa, David Nykl, Paul McGillion, Torri Higginson, Rachel Luttrell
  • Format: Widescreen, Color, DVD, NTSC
  • Originally Published on my Live Journal 6/07/2007 (both entries), now hosted on Dreamwidth

This post is a combination of two posts from Live Journal reacting to the Stargate: Atlantis episode “Sunday” which was quite a surprise, to say the least. I’m leaving the content of these entries intact and only correcting spelling mistakes, typos, and the occasional wrong word.

Part 1

Ok, so what the …?

I watched “Sunday” last night, and was it just me or was the episode VERY very weird?

And, I not just talking about the fact the story wasn’t told in order – I’ve seen that before, I get it, heck -the idea of telling a story back-to-front actually goes back to a lot of classic film noirs like Sunset Boulevard and Double Indemnity.

But the non-linear storytelling aside, uh, huh? The entire episode had an almost dream-like quality to it. I actually almost expected someone to wake up at the end and say, “it’s all just a dream”? Ya’ know what I mean? Especially in the last scene. But I’m getting ahead of myself.

OK – first, who was the guy that was hitting on Dr. Weir? I don’t think I’ve ever seen him before, and yet Weir (despite trying to brush him off in one scene) seemed, when talking to Teyla later, to be interested in him. Then she drops him like a rock? What? I mean, really – Weir is not that capricious! And she’s been married before – why the heck was she acting like a teenager on her first date about the entire thing?

Second – MANDATORY REST DAY??? And this is the first we’ve heard about it in three years? I’ve WORKED in 24/7 industries, and it simply doesn’t work that way. You get days off, but everyone does NOT take the SAME day off. Believe me. And that’s in retail/grocery – hospitals, emergency services, etc, heck, even restaurants, all work like that. You are more likely to work Thursday through Sunday and have Monday off. Obviously, on Atlantis – the gate room needs to be manned 24/7, as does the infirmary, and somebody better be watching the long-range scanners (in case the Wraith show up, tho’ we haven’t actually seen the Wraith in a while). So, what’s with the sudden mandatory rest day?

I mean, don’t get me wrong – I actually liked the idea of seeing what everyone does on their day off (who figured John for a golfer or Lorne for an amateur artist?), but in terms of everyone having the same day off, it’s like, huh?

And if it was for dramatic effect – to see a quiet day suddenly going haywire – then they totally lost the dramatic effect by jumping back and forth in time.

OK, about the jumping back and forth in time, to me it almost looked like they were trying to save the episode in the editing – that it had gone waaaaaay too long, or they’d forgotten to film the exposition, or something else disastrous happened (a roll of film went missing?) but it looked like they were trying to salvage something, rather than doing something cool. That’s just my opinion. (For the record, I thought “The Ark” would have worked better dramatically without the time-jump. I mean, you knew John and Rodney would both make it!)

Right, now… CARSON – they killed CARSON???????? What he’d ever do to anybody? Dr. Carson Beckett was always sweet and kind and cute as heck (those eyes!). He, Rodney, Zelenka, were always favorites of mine (as are Weir & Sheppard). But all the way through the episode, it was like everyone was ignoring Carson, paying him no mind. I mean, really, all he wanted was for someone to go fishing with him. (And I had the sneaking suspicion that Rodney, despite what he said to Katie, would have actually enjoyed fishing with Carson).

The scene with Rodney, in a suit & tie in Carson’s rooms, packing the photographs and such was heartbreaking though. And I couldn’t help but notice the number of people in suits (not uniforms) at the funeral. Waaaahhhh! (Update: Those in suits would be Atlantis’ civilians, as opposed to the military officers in uniform.)

Oh – and the bagpipes, um, nice try guys, but – that was some of the worst bagpipe music I’ve ever heard (my local police pipe & drum band sounds better). Also, for a funeral they should have been playing “Amazing Grace”, it’s traditional, especially for someone who’s died in the line of duty. And, if not that, they should have played “Scotland the Brave” which would have worked fine.

Still – no body, so HE’S NOT DEAD!!!! Ever notice on detective stories, especially on TV, if there’s no body, if you didn’t actually see it – the character comes back? And I’ve heard rumors, just like I heard rumors about “Sunday” (ah, the net, couldn’t keep a secret…). And they brought Daniel back on SG1 after a whole season, so there’s hope. (Update: Nope, five seasons of Atlantis and no Carson. Sigh.)

Finally, that last scene between Carson and Rodney? Huh? That was strange! Very strange! I need to watch the episode again, but it almost felt like Rodney was also dead – or dreaming. And that can’t kill off my Rodney!!!

And that brings me back to my original point – the entire episode, and I mean the entire episode felt incredibly strange. It was like, there was something else going on, especially with the weird time-jumps. OK, putting aside extra-“filmic” excuses (the film went missing, the episode ran long, etc.), I almost thought that, in the end, they’d pull back and show the entire episode was from Carson’s point-of-view, that is, his dead pov. How poor Carson never felt appreciated? How he felt everyone was always brushing him off? That would have made sense. As would have the funeral then, with Weir’s speech. Even the bad bagpipe music would fit as Carson’s pov (he’d naturally be in a position to criticize the bagpipe music – he is Scottish!)

Part 2

Well, I re-watched “Sunday” again. I still think the ep. is weird — very weird. It had a whole sense of unreality to it (like the Blake’s 7 episode “Orbit”, strangely enough).

The bagpipe music didn’t seem quite so bad, but it definitely could have been better. Trust me.
And louder. NOTHING is louder than bagpipes in an enclosed space! (I’ll never forget hearing the Muskegon Police Pipes & Drum band playing at the Scottish Festival/Ceille in a very tiny hall. It was loud! Very loud! You might think your average freight train is a bit noisy but that’s peanuts compared to a Bagpipe and Drum marching band in an enclosed space!) “Amazing Grace” or “Scotland the Brave” would have worked better in the Stargate: Atlantis episode than whatever it was the poor fellow in a kilt was trying to play. Unsuccessfully.

OK, the episode, “Sunday”, couldn’t have been from Beckett’s pov, there was just too much going on that he wasn’t privy too. Which makes the last scene even more confusing! In a sense, it was like Rodney was also dead (please no!) and it made me re-watch “Tao of Rodney” again (which must now be one of my all-time favorite eps. of Stargate: Atlantis). I just didn’t get it. Once of the post-Sunday fics I read said that Carson had Ascended, but some reading on the Save Carson website (www.savecarson.com) nixed that idea.

Anyway, I stand by what I said, “no body, he’s NOT dead”! And it seemed weird, just strange, the skip from the explosion to Carson’s funeral.

I WANT MY SCOTTISH DOCTOR BACK!

Oh, and if they get rid of a certain Canadian physicist. I just won’t be able to watch the show anymore. And probably ditto for a certain cute-as-a-button Czech physicist/engineer!

Update

These two entries originally published to my Live Journal blog and now hosted on Dreamwidth are my original reactions to a very emotional episode of Stargate: Atlantis. I enjoyed that series very much, though I was not a fan of season four and ended up not getting it on DVD. I do have season 5 though. Rodney remains my favorite character, and I had seen David Hewlett on other series. I also liked Zelenka, and David Nykl ended-up on Arrow. I’ve seen Paul McGillion a few times since Stargate: Atlantis ended. As I noted above in my “update” comments – Dr. Beckett wasn’t brought back, but they did introduce Jewel Staite (Firefly) as the new medical doctor. And yes, that is Jason Momoa of Game of Thrones and Aquaman fame. I saw him first on this show! I miss this show, it had a different vibe than most American SF.

Advertisements