Book Review – Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

  • Title: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child (Script for a Play)
  • Author: J.K. Rowling, Jack Thorne
  • Date Reviewed on GoodReads: 09/11/2016

This is a script book – a script for a play. I knew that going in, and I’ve read many television and film scripts before (though not as many plays) so I knew going in what to expect (dialogue labeled by character, very little description, etc). I also found that I was quickly absorbed into the plot as I have been by the rest of the Harry Potter series, and especially during the second act.

Harry’s son, Albus Serveus Potter is about to start his first year at Hogwart’s. But Albus and Harry are already having father-son problems. Harry isn’t really sure how to be a parent – and Albus doesn’t like being the son of the “oh so famous” Harry Potter. That would be enough fuel for a more generic “next generation” novel – but Rowling is a stronger writer than that and produces a much stronger play. In the first few scenes, Albus leaves his family and is happy about it (but for entirely different reasons that Harry’s joy at leaving his foster family) and on the train to Hogwarts meets Scorpius Malfoy who’s sitting all alone on the train because nasty rumors are already circulating about his parentage. Albus and Scorpius become fast friends – much to the horror of Harry. Albus is also sorted into Slytherin House.

Albus over-hears part of a conversation between Amos Diggory (father of Cedric Diggory) and his father, Harry. When Harry denies having access to a time turner and refuses to help “bring back Cedric” – Albus starts to jump to conclusions. When he finds out the Ministry of Magic has a Time Turner, and it’s in Hermione’s office (Hermione being the Minister of Magic), Albus talks Scorpius into helping him steal it. The two then plot to keep Cedric alive by stopping him from winning the first task during the Triwizarding cup.

However, though they succeed in causing him to fail – when they return to the present, things have changed, instead of marrying Hermione and running a joke shop – Ron is serious and married to Padil. Rose Granger-Weasley no longer exists. Hermione, rather than Minister of Magic, is a teacher – and not a good one. Albus and Scorpius realize they’ve made a horrible mistake.

Unfortunately, in trying to fix it – they make things worse, much worse, and we see a world where Harry Potter died and Voldemort won the Battle at Hogwarts. Now the world “lives” in an era of Nazi-like tyranny – with Muggles being sent to concentration camps, and upstanding wizards being in fear of their lives. Hermione and Ron are outlaws, and Snape is alive and with them. Ron, Snape, and Hermione give their lives so Scorpius can escape and reverse what has happened (Albus no longer exists because Harry died.)

Scorpius is able to somewhat set things right – but someone who had pushed Albus and Scorpius to use the time-turner in the first place turns out to be not who they think she is. The last half of the second act is a race – a race to prevent a re-writing of everything we know about Hogwarts and the characters who occupy that world.

This novel is about generational prejudice. Harry doesn’t want Albus to be friends with Scorpius because he’s Draco’s son. And Harry (especially in his alternate guise) is, well, not as much a “controlling” father – as someone who in trying to spare his son pain – fails to let him make his own choices, and even his own mistakes. The rest of the Wizarding World has similar issues – having ignored the signs of Voldemort’s return while Harry and company were at school – they now lean too far in the other direction and are beginning to see Death Eaters under every tree and bush. Especially for the children and grandchildren of Death Eaters and their allies – the prevailing thought is that family association makes one guilty. This is unfair to children like Scorpius, who really is a very good, yet lonely, child.

Advertisements

Harry Potter – Neville and His Wand

mellro:

edwardspoonhands:

karenhallion:

miss-nobody13:

itsprongs:

Oh god guys. JK Rowling is a genius, and so is this person.

the thing I love about this fandom is that there are 7 books and 8 movies to observe. so every once in a while some blessed soul finds a piece of information that makes all the magic resurface again

Mind. Blown.

Oh Lord…it’s a metaphor too. It’s symbolic of Neville holding on to his past, the horrors of what happened to his parents, of being a passive vessel for that atrocity. As if the terrible thing kept happening and would never stop happening.

When he moves forward and becomes part of his own story instead of the story of his past, his strength surges.

TEAM NEVILLE FOR LIFE

I love the analysis here.

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

  • Title:  Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
  • Director:  Mike Newell
  • Date:  2005
  • Studio:  Warner Brothers
  • Genre:  Fantasy
  • Cast:  Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Emma Watson, Robbie Coltrane, Warwick Davis, Ralph Fiennes, Michael Gambon, Robert Hardy, Jason Isaacs, Gary Oldman, Miranda Richardson, Alan Rickman, Maggie Smith, David Tennant
  • Format:  Color, Widescreen
  • DVD Format:  R1, NTSC

“Dark and difficult times lay ahead, soon we must all face the choice between what is right and what is easy.  But remember this – you have friends here, you’re not alone.”  — Professor Dumbledore

With Goblet of Fire, the Harry Potter series take a turn for the darker, and the new director, Mike Newell, doesn’t shoot the film and its environment the way his predecessors did.  Rather than giving us lovely, beautiful shots and placing the characters in them perfectly – Newell concentrates on showing us close-ups of the characters’ faces.  Not as interesting an approach to watch, but, on the other hand, it does add to the emotional feel of the film.

This is the first Harry Potter film to have a very episodic feel to it.  We see a brief, almost prologue, at the Quiddich World Cup, which is broken up by a show of force by the Death Eaters, the first and second Tri-Wizarding Tournament tasks, the Yule Ball, and the final task and Harry’s confrontation with Voldemort. Each episode is well realized and told, but of course details from the book are lost, as they have been for all of the Harry Potter films.

Still, it is a very good movie, and a good adaptation of the novel.  The Wizarding World is again expanded and Harry goes with Ron and his family to the Quiddich World Cup; then at Hogwarts, exchange students from Drumstrang and Madam Beaux Batons Academy come to Hogwarts for the Tri-Wizarding Tournament.  It’s interesting to note that apparently Drumstrang is a boys school and Beaux Batons a girls school.  Only Hogwarts, of the three Wizarding Schools, appears to be co-ed.  A champion is to be chosen from each school, but he or she must be seventeen or older. Yet, not only is Hogwarts represented by Cedric Diggory, but also by Harry.  This causes Harry some problems, as even Ron is jealous and angry.  However, Ron and Harry work out their differences after Ron sees the danger Harry is in during the first task of challenging a dragon.  During the second task, Harry comes in last as he’s determined to rescue all the kidnapped people (Ron, Hermione, Cho, and Fleur’s younger sister).  Cedric and Krum save their “treasures” and Harry rescues Ron and Fleur’s sister.  His bravery and determination, however, earn him extra points for moral fibre, and he ends up in second place behind Cedric.

The third task is a maze, with the Tri-Wizarding Cup hidden somewhere inside.  After spooky challenges, Harry and Cedric take the Cup at the same time.  But it’s a portkey, transporting them to the graveyard where Tom Riddle’s parents are buried.  Cedric is killed.  Wormtail performs an incantation which brings back Voldemort.  Harry and Voldemort duel, but their wands become locked.  Harry escapes, bringing Cedric back and sobbing.

In a sober end-of-year lecture, Dumbledore informs all the Hogwarts students that Cedric was killed by Voldemort, who’s back.

Recommendation:  See It
Rating: 5 of 5 Stars
Next Film:  Henry V