- Title: Doctor Who: Love and War
- Series: Doctor Who The New Adventures
- Author: Paul Cornell
- Date Reviewed on GoodReads: 6/18/2020
Love and War is a Doctor Who tie-in novel from Virgin Publishing Company’s Doctor Who The New Adventures featuring the Seventh Doctor as played by Sylvester McCoy and his companion, Ace (aka Dorothy McShane). The first half of Love and War I really liked. In the far future, an empty planet is discovered that is so perfect it’s named “Heaven”. It becomes an intergalactic graveyard for both Humans and Draconians, who have finally brokered a peace after a very long and deadly war. There are also, now that the war is over, small human and Draconian settlements on Heaven. The Doctor and Ace arrive, though Ace is out of sorts because she’s still dealing with the death of a friend. The Doctor is also acting, well, weird. On Heaven, Ace meets the Travellers, a group of people who travel from place to place, with no fixed abode and little past or future. They share leadership responsibilities and make all decisions together, through consensus in ‘Puter-Space, a type of Virtual Reality. Ace is particularly taken with a male traveler named, “Jan”. She thinks she’s in love with him during much of the novel. And she loves him because he reminds her of the Doctor but he’s human. She’s also hurting from losing her mate.
The Doctor meets Dr. Bernice (Benny) Summerfield, an archaeologist who is investigating a huge arch, which is a ruin left by the extremely old and extremely dead former civilization on Heaven. The Doctor is also trying to find an obscure banned book, which frankly feels like a McGuffin at first, though it does fit into the plot.
All of this is fine, and honestly, an entire book of the Doctor and Ace on vacation on a paradise planet would have been fine, especially as the two really need time to catch their breath. Or even a fairly standard alien invasion would have been fine. But it turns out that Heaven is a farm world for the Hoothi, an alien species that farms entire worlds for “meat” which they then form into slaves, spaceships, etc. The Hoothi are a fungoid species and anything or anyone infected by their spores becomes one with the Hoothi and they can be controlled by these very weird aliens. The Hoothi can also raise the dead, use them as soldiers, slaves, workers, etc.
Essentially, about halfway through the book, it turns into “The Doctor vs. Zombies”, which has the problem of “how do you kill something that’s already dead”? To make matters worse, no one is reliable because anyone can be or could have been infected with spores at any time and become an agent of the Hoothi. The Doctor warns Ace about getting involved with Jan, but, unfortunately, she interprets this as jealousy.
Needless to say, the Doctor, through some colossal manipulation manages to outwit the Hoothi and defeat them, saving Heaven in the process, for the most part. But the victory comes at a high and personal cost for Ace. The book ends with her not even willing to go into the TARDIS, and running off with Bernice instead.
I liked the beginning of this book – but the fungus-creatures and zombies were too much for me. I’m not a fan of horror really and this book got a little too gross. Still, even though I can only give it a rating of 3 out of 5, I recommend it, at least for completeness sake, since Doctor Who the New Adventures is a long-running and interconnected series.