Iron Man 3

  • Title:  Iron Man 3
  • Director:  Shane Black
  • Date:  2013
  • Studio:  Paramount, Marvel
  • Genre:  Action, Fantasy
  • Cast:  Robert Downey Jr., Gwyneth Paltrow, Guy Pearce, Don Cheadle, Jon Favreau, Rebecca Hall, Ben Kingsley, Paul Bettany
  • Format:  Color, Widescreen
  • DVD Format:  NTSC, R1

When I saw Iron Man 3 in the theater last summer I was somewhat disappointed.  I bought the DVD anyway, and having watched it a couple of times, I still think it wasn’t as good as it could have been.  But I bought the film because I like Robert Downey Jr. and he does seem to be born to play the part of Tony Stark aka Iron Man.

The interesting part of the story is that Tony, after the events in New York, in The Avengers, is suffering from PTSD and panic attacks – not that he seems willing to deal with his trauma.  He and Pepper are living together, but arguing as ever.

The film uses a voice-over by Tony to try to connect and explain events.  In a tag during the credits, we’ll learn he’s talking to Dr. Bruce Banner.  However, even with the voice-over, this film is confusing and hard to follow.  And even after multiple viewings – that doesn’t improve matters, at all.  And that remains one of the prime problems with the film – without a good story, a story that grabs you with it’s characters – or an unique and meaningful plot, the best action sequences in the world can still seem boring.  So, the film doesn’t really work because it’s confusing, and the action sequences don’t really work because they have little meaning.

The plot involves a series of “terrorist” bombings – bombings which eventually turn out not to be the result of terrorist bombs at all, but a new, experimental military technology called Extremis.  Extremis was invented by Aldrich Killian (Guy Pearce) a man Tony had met at a party before he became Iron Man.  Tony blew the guy off, causing him to obtain military contracts to develop Extremis – rather than using it as a genetic treatment for physical disabilities and medical illnesses.  Though, given the little we see of Killian’s character, it’s doubtful he would have used Extremis for purely “peaceful” means even if Stark Industries had backed his research.

The terrorist bombings, by a man called, The Mandarin, turn out to be a charade – The Mandarin is Trevor Slattery, a British actor, hired by Killian to put a false face on the bombings – which are actually a side effect of Extremis going wrong.  S.H.I.E.L.D., meanwhile, had tried to get Tony to work with them to stop The Mandarin – but he refuses as he thinks it’s none of his business.  When Happy is injured in an random Mandarin attack, however, Tony takes it personally – and not only threatens the Mandarin but gives out his home address in a public press conference.

Tony’s actions prove to be as dumb as that sounds – as the Mandarin attacks and destroys his Malibu home.  Tony, in escaping, ends-up in Tennessee, where he is given help by a young, geeky, know-it-all kid.  And yes, that part of the plot was extremely annoying. Pepper disappears for the vast majority of the plot – and Tony’s running around with a kid.

Tony is in Tennessee for a reason, though – before the public threats of the Mandarin started, there was another explosion with the same heat signature.  Tony figures there’s a connection, and in Tennessee – he finds it, thus leading him to Trevor, and then to Killian. But Killian meanwhile has taken Pepper and exposed her to Extremis.  Thus, Tony ‘s final battle is more about saving the woman he loves than about stopping Killian and Extremis. This should have made the film work better – however, not only is Tony helped by Rhody, now the “Iron Patriot” but about 30 remotely activated Iron Man suits join in the final battle. Therefore, in the final battle – it’s very difficult to figure out who’s who and what’s going on (both Tony and Rhody get in and out of various suits throughout the battle).

Still, at the end, Pepper almost dies, but Extremis saves her.  Tony realises how much he loves Pepper, and even has the shrapnel and electromagnet removed from his chest, and one is left with the idea that he might, finally, become a better person without relying on his suit of iron.  Well, until the next Avengers film.

The problem with Iron Man 3 is twofold – it doesn’t expand the universe at all, it simply introduces yet another villain, and this villain isn’t even real – the Mandarin is a sham.  An Killian, though nasty, is somewhat finite as a villain – Extremis doesn’t work.  It, temporarily, does as promised – even regrowing limbs, but eventually the patient blows-up.  Not exactly a medical miracle.  And secondly, it becomes just another chapter in an on-going story that never ends.  There’s no beginning, middle, end structure to the Iron Man films – so there’s no growth.  In the second film, I felt Tony had slid backwards to his original party self; in this one – Party Tony is in a flashback, but there’s still no real growth or change.  And the end scenes, which do hint at change — Tony realising his feelings for Pepper, Tony having the shrapnel and magnet removed, etc., all seem fake and short-lived.  We know Iron Man will be back, so what’s the point?

I did like the scenes between Pepper and Tony at the beginning and end of the film, but overall, Gwyneth Paltrow is almost criminally under-used in this film.  She needed either, her own storyline, or to be with Tony in Tennessee doing research – not simply arguing with Tony at the beginning, and being a victim at the end, until Tony tries to rescue her and she ends up rescuing herself instead.

Recommendation:  For die-hard Marvel fans Only
Rating:  3 Stars
Next Film:  Justice League:  Flashpoint Paradox

Ironman 2

  • Title:  Ironman 2
  • Director: Jon Favreau
  • Date:  2010
  • Studio:  Paramount, Marvel
  • Genre:  Action, Fantasy
  • Cast:  Robert Downey Jr, Gwyneth Paltrow, Sam Rockwell, Scarlett Johansson, Don Cheadle
  • Format:  Color, Widescreen
  • DVD Format:  R1, NTSC

“You want my property, you can’t have it.  But I did you a big favor, I’ve successfully privatized world peace.”  — Tony Stark

“You are running out of both time and options.  Unfortunately, the device that’s keeping you alive is also killing you.”  — Jarvis

“You want to do this whole lone gunslinger act, and it’s unnecessary.  You don’t have to do this alone.” — Rhodey
“You know, I wish I could believe that, I really do.  But you gotta trust me.  Contrary to popular belief, I know exactly what I’m doing.”  — Tony

The film does open with a re-cap of the audio from Tony’s press conference at the end of the first Ironman film — played out against a man in Russia assembling his own arc reactor and Ironman-like suit. We will later discover this is Whiplash.

Tony, as Ironman, literally drops in to a rock concert-like opening for Stark Expo, complete with screaming fans and Rocketts.  He’s back to the arrogent, egomaniac — wild, and irresponsible, challenging anyone and everyone who is in his way, including a Senate sub-committee.

Normally, in a sequel to a heroic adventure, I would expect that the hero, having learned his true path in the first film (or book) would spend the second film facing down a bigger, badder, meaner challenge.  It’s nice if there’s more character interaction and development; or if  the world opens up, so to speak, widening the area where the hero plays.  However, in Ironman 2, Tony seems to have slipped backwards — once again becoming the irresponsible playboy, without a thought for how his actions affect others.

It’s soon revealed that Tony is dying.  The Palladium core of the arc reactor in his chest that keeps him alive, is also slowly poisoning him.  Tony begins to give away his things, such as donating his modern art collection to the Boy Scouts of America.  He also makes Pepper the CEO and chairman of his company. Their conversation when he does so, is at breakneck speed and great fun to watch.

Tony then goes to the Grand Prix race in Monaco.  Pepper, Happy, and a new Stark Industries employee named Natalie Rushman (later revealed to be a S.H.I.E.L.D. agent, named Natasha) accompany Tony to Monaco. There he’s challenged by Justin Hammer, CEO of Hammer Industries – a weapons manufacturing company and former business rival of Stark’s.  Hammer wants to build his own Ironman suits as well, to sell to the US Armed Forces.

Tony slips away from the meeting, and tests his blood toxicity (with a device that looks very much like the type of portable blood sugar monitor used by diabetics).  Next you see him, he’s preparing to drive the race car he was only supposed to be sponsoring for the Grand Prix.  Pepper is livid and has Natalie find Happy so they can try to stop Tony from getting himself  killed.   During the race, Whiplash arrives and causes havoc — attacking cars and then deliberately crashing Tony’s race car.  Tony manages to free himself, and with a little intervention from Happy and Pepper is briefly rescued.  Pepper throws him a red suitcase, and Tony steps into the Ironman suit and challenges Whiplash.  He wins and the villian is carted off by the police.

On the flight back to the US, Pepper does ask Tony what he’s not telling her.  He talks about cancelling his birthday party and going with her to Venice.  Again, their dialogue together is cute, but Tony isn’t really telling her what’s going on.

Whiplash escapes prison, and is convinced to work for Justin Hammer.  He, does, however, have his own agenda.

Meanwhile, the night of  his birthday party, Rhodey finds Tony in his workroom, alone, and in bad shape. Tony gives a wild birthday party, and when Pepper tries to stop him — he goes even more wild, destroying things.  Rhodey shows up in one of Tony’s old Ironman suits and the two go at it.  In the end, Rhodey escapes with the suit and takes it to the Air Force.

The next day, Fury, of S.H.I.E.L.D., arrives and gives Tony lithium dioxide to counter the effects of  the Palladium poisoning.  He also introduces a more important part of the plot; that Howard Stark said the arc reactor was only a stepping stone to something greater, and Tony was the key.  Tony’s confused by this, but takes his father’s trunk and returns to the Orphanage (his home) where he discovers Agent Phil Coulson will be his body guard and babysitter.

Going through he father’s things, he discovers an old 16mm film of his father’s speech for the opening of Stark Expo.  At the end of his practicing the speech, Howard Stark addresses Tony directly.

Tony goes to see Pepper at Stark Industries and again is incapable of telling her how he feels (partially because she cuts him off) or that he’s dying.  But when he sees the Stark Expo model leaning against a wall, he realizes there’s more to it than meets the eye.  He brings it back to his workshop, and has Jarvis render it into a 3-D working model.  Working with the model, he realizes it’s an atom for a new element. Tony builds a Large Hadron Collider in his workshop and creates the new element.

As before, Tony is at his best, when he is alone and working on a problem or to build something.  The man is most definitely an engineer.  And I still love Jarvis and the 3-D holographic displays as Tony figures stuff out and manipulates parts of the rendered drawing with his hands.  (I use AutoCAD at work — I wish it was that easy!)  The final shot of Tony surrounded by dots of blue light, representing his new element is absolutely gorgeous!  I loved it!  Tony puts the new element in his arc reactor core which will help his “dying” problem.  In other words, he’s no longer being poisoned slowly.

Justin Hammer turns out to be a bully — taking Whiplash’s pet bird when he isn’t delivering fast enough on making suits that imitate Tony’s Ironman.  Rhodey delivers his suit to the Air Force who deliver it to Hammer.

At Stark Expo, Hammer introduces his battle drones, and his VTRB (Variable Threat Response Battlesuit).  But Wisplash takes control of the suits remotely and chaos reigns.  Even Rhodey in his own VTRB suit can’t control it.  Tony has Jarvis hack into Rhodey’s suit, granting him control at least.  Pepper contacts the police to try to bring some control to the chaos.  Eventually, Tony and Rhodey defeat Whiplash and his drones, but Whiplash has one final act to play — all the drones contain bombs.  Tony rushes off and rescues Pepper.  She quits as  CEO of Stark Industries.

Ironman 2 has some fun moments, and I liked the advancement of  Tony and Pepper’s relationship.  I also found the one step forward two steps back approach to Tony and Pepper’s relationship to be frustrating almost to the point of annoyance.  Tony and Pepper are cute together.  She can improve him, but they also seem to be always moving in opposite directions, unable to stand still long enough to really meet and know what the other is saying.  But I also found it odd that dying was used by Tony as an excuse to go back to his irresponsible playboy ways.  And, in a sense there was too many “big action scenes” and not enough character development (even for the villian — the only place his name was used was the back of the DVD box).  A sequel should further develop the main character’s arc, but in this film it seems to go backwards instead.   However, Robert Downey Jr and Gwyneth Paltrow again knock it out of the park, doing their best with what they are given.  And I like Tony when he’s alone and acting as an engineer.  But overall, a little disappointing.

Recommendation:  See it.  May as well to keep up with the various Marvel movies leading up to The Avengers.
Rating:  3.8 out of  5 Stars
Next Film:  Sherlock Holmes:  A Game of  Shadows


  • Title:  Ironman
  • Director:  Jon Favreau
  • Date:  2008
  • Studio:  Paramount, Marvel
  • Genre:  Action, Fantasy
  • Cast:  Robert Downey Jr, Jeff Bridges, Gwyneth Paltrow
  • Format:  Color, Widescreen
  • DVD Format:  R1, NTSC

“So you’re a man who has everything and nothing.”  — Yinsen (when Tony tells him he has no family)

“Thank you for saving me.”  — Tony Stark
“Don’t waste it.  Don’t waste your life.”  — Yinsen

“I saw young Americans killed by the very weapons I created to defend them and protect them.  And I saw that I had become part of a system that is comfortable with zero accountability.”  — Tony Stark

When we first meet Tony Stark, well, when we first meet him — he’s getting blown up by one of his own weapons manufacturing company’s weapons — but the film quickly flashes back and shows us the previous thirty-six hours of Tony’s life.  Tony Stark is rich, powerful, irresponsible, a playboy, and a bit of a jerk.  He has no idea what his own company is doing, though he thinks he does, and he probably doesn’t care.  On a publicity trip to Iraq or Afghanistan to demonstrate his company new weapon, the Jericho missile (a multi-warhead missile that reminds me of the “probes” in Stargate:  Atlantis), Tony’s convoy home is attacked.  And thus we are back where the teaser to the film starts – the convoy is blown-up, and Tony is blown-up by a Stark Industries weapon.

Tony wakes in a rebel camp, the multi-national Ten Rings group.  He’s tortured, but his life is also saved by an electro-magnet installed in his chest by a man also being held captive, Yinsen.  Yinsen is learnéd, a doctor, and had met Tony before at a lecture, though Tony doesn’t remember him.  The rebels demand that Tony build them a Jericho rocket.  Tony refuses.  Then he agrees, but instead of building the rebels a weapon, he builds a suit (and a miniature arc reactor to power the electro-magnet in his chest keeping the shrapnel from entering his heart).  His plan is for he and Yinsen to get out of there.  Yinsen dies in the attempt, but Tony not only gets out, he uses a flame-thrower to burn-up the cache of weapons and several of the rebels.

Rhodey, Tony’s friend from the Air Force, rescues him and returns him to Pepper Potts, his administrative assistant.  Tony refuses medical attention, asks for a cheeseburger, and has Pepper arrange a press conference.  At the conference, he announces Stark Industries will no longer manufacture weapons.  Obadiah steps in and shuts him up.  Tony isn’t pleased.

Tony has shown himself  to be an excellent engineer — with the ability to not only plan how to make something, but to actually assemble it — with skills in welding, forging metal, building things, and improving things.  He uses the paladium from some of the weapons in the rebel cave to forge a ring that powers his arc reactor, as well as making the Mark I  Ironman suit.

Tony returns to “The Orphanage”, his home in presumably California, and begins working on improving his Arc Reactor.  Obadiah tells him “the board” thinks he has PTSD, and orders an injunction against him, freezing him out.  Tony still insists Stark Industries will no longer make weapons.  He returns to his workshop and starts the Mark II Ironman suit.  Tony, again, is an excellent engineer — and some of the best scenes in the film are of him working, by himself, to solve a problem.

And by the bye — I WANT a Jarvis!  A computerized butler, assistant, and 3-D computer interface.  Jarvis goes on my short list of SF inventions I want (along with, say a TARDIS), but I digress.

Tony goes to the Fire-Fighters ball that one of  his charities sponsors, and dances with Pepper, but then discovers (a) Stark Industries is selling weapons to the enemy, (b) Obadiah froze Tony out so he could continue to do so.  Finding about about Stark weapons being used to target Gulmira, Yinsen’s home town, Tony gets into the Ironman gear and decides to do something.  He kicks butt, basically.

More confirmation that Obadiah is not Tony’s friend:  he’s paying the rebels (in cash and weapons), and asked them to kill Tony Stark.  And this was before Tony becomes Ironman.  Obadiah takes the pieces of Tony’s original survival suit (which were left in the desert) to Level 16 of Stark Industries, so he can make more suits.  Tony needs proof of this so he sends in Pepper to get that proof.  But she doesn’t immediately agree — that their conversation says a lot about both characters and their relationship.

“There is the next mission and nothing else.”  — Tony
“Is that so?  Well, then, I quit.”  — Pepper
“You stood by my side all these years while I reaped the benefits of destruction.  And now that I’m trying to protect the people I put in harm’s way; You’re going to walk out?” — Tony
“You’re going to kill yourself, Tony.  I’m not going to be a part of  it.” — Pepper
“I shouldn’t be alive, unless it was for a reason.  I’m not crazy, Pepper.  I just finally know what I have to do.  And I know in my heart that it’s right.” — Tony

Tony is learning responsibility, and he’s starting to acknowledge his feelings for Pepper.  Feelings she’s returned but for the fact that he’s her boss.  But there is a caring between the two.

Pepper gets the info and runs into Agent Coulson of S.H.I.E.L.D.  But Obadiah gets to Tony first, stuns him, takes the arc reactor, threatens to kill Pepper, and informs Tony he’s going to make an army of Ironman suits to sell to the highest bidder.  Dying, Tony tries to get to his workshop to put the old arc reactor in his chest.  Meanwhile, Pepper is frantic — worrying about Tony.  She sends Rhodey to him.

Tony is able to get in the Ironman suit and fight Obadiah.  Though S.H.I.E.L.D. prepares an alibi for Tony – he admits before a press conference that he is Ironman – cut to end credits.

Ironman walks the path of many more traditional hero stories — the hero (to be) is a jerk, with problems understanding the real world.  The hero faces a life-altering threat.  A mentor helps the hero see his true path, but dies.  The hero emerges in a new guise but isn’t quite ready or the completed/perfect hero yet. There’s another crisis.  By walking through the fire of  the second crisis — the hero becomes the final, complete, perfected hero he is meant to be.  However, the film does it with style — and the artful talents of Robert Downey Jr and Gwyneth Paltrow — both of whom are excellent in this.  Enjoyable and fun!

Recommendation:  See it!
Rating:  4 out of  5 Stars
Next Film:  Ironman II